A rant.
I orbit around and exist within several different circles/spheres, one of which is women in business. In this space, there is sometimes a playful dig at the whole ‘mediocre white male confidence’ thing, and an acknowledgement of the ‘boys club esque’ ways of doing things in recent (and unfortunately still current) history.
I recently attended what was supposed to be a workshop, as I understood it to be, within a community that I highly regard (run by a woman) for people in a specific field. (It wasn’t a space specifically for women in business - the above paragraph was just for context of my perspective - which I know FDSers will understand and appreciate! However, this woman is openly not much of a fan of the patriarchy, so to speak.)
At this event, there was a feature/guest speaker and he happened to be male. A ’veteran’ if you will, in the particular specialty he was to teach on. I was looking forward to this space because I have a LOT to learn on that particular topic!!
Well, oh my BARF.
99% of the session was this person name dropping the people he’s worked with over the years, rambling nonsensical anecdotes and providing close to ZERO value. Many of the participants were drooling over this clout signaling, but what was the actual value that was provided? The dude verbally vomited random shit and wouldn’t hardly let the interviewer get a question in edgeways - although I’m not sure whether the interviewer had any questions prepared at all, or just couldn't/didn't feel confident in leading/directing the discussion.
The whole time I was thinking, ok, ok, when is he actually going to get to the MEAT of it? To me - It really was a blatant, arrogant & obvious display of not having got to where he is through merit/skill/intelligence, but through contacts and boys club ‘mateship’. Look, I’m not saying the guy didn’t have any skill, he surely must to have the longevity that he has had in his field (other than being propped up by the patriarchy blah blah blah), and contacts are of course important for anyone, but he certainly had no skill in CONVEYING his knowledge, or imparting anything of actual value.
It really bothers me when people don’t realise that teaching/communicating is an art/skill in and of itself, and that just because someone is good at something, doesn’t mean they are good at teaching/communicating about it?
I’m definitely oscillating between feeling dirty for given him so much of my time and attention and him having some kind of a ‘wank’, and feeling like surely there must be something wrong with me and I’m ungrateful when several others expressed their gratitudes etc etc etc
I needed to have a rant somewhere where people might understand!! It’s hours of my time I will never get back and it was so poor quality an experience - which is NOT was I was expecting from this particular space as it is consistently HIGH quality.
I really should have left about a third of the way in, but I thought 'surely this is going to be redirected to somewhere more useful soon...?" and then I think I sucked myself into the sunken cost fallacy... UHG!
I see this so often it makes me sick. I've resorted to extreme niches of my interests and work just to avoid the narcissism plaguing every corner of the earth.
I know how you feel. I could write books on this topic. If men had truly nothing left, no possessions, skills, nothing… They’d still have the *audacity*.
I was at a conference one time and there was this one guy (in the audience) who kept asking so many (mundane) questions, the speaker couldn’t even get a word in. My friend at that time told me “there’s always this one guy who just loves to hear himself speak“.
I had a similar experience with a personality coach at work... He was supposed to help the team at work with understanding each other's personalities, but he ended up just talking about his own shit for hours.
I just attended another event... Totally different situation. Happened to be run by a woman. No guest on this one. It went 1 hour over scheduled time. Which would normally annoy the hell out of me, but (1) I had the spare time to stay, and; (2) She provided SO MUCH VALUE how could I not? it was SO worth my while! And it was totally free??? The above situation in my original post with the dude was paid. WOMEN ARE GENERALLY SO MUCH MORE EXCELLENT.
Oh god. The same thing happened when my company brought in a “motivational speaker”. Guy was full of shit, and spent the whole time trying to plug his book.
Omg 100% he probably doesn’t have that much skill and clearly has perfected the art of playing politics to get ahead. I work in tech an it’s baffling the opportunities these guys get just because they schmooze and talk football and golf or whatever. The patriarchy is alive and well, and it’s as bad as it ever was.